Short answer. We took every 2025 residential complaint in the City of Calgary's public Assessment Review Board dataset, matched 1,685 of them to the assessment roll, and counted how many ended with a lower assessed value by any route. 70% did.
The two public files
Everything comes from the City of Calgary's open data portal. The first file is the Assessment Review Board complaints dataset [1]. It lists complaints by address and year, how each one ended, and for most of them the value before and after. The second is the City's assessment roll, which carries the current value of every property.
Anyone can download both. You do not need an account.
What we counted
We took the residential complaints filed against the 2025 roll and matched each one to its property. 1,685 matched cleanly. For each of those, we asked one question: did the assessed value go down, by any amount, by any route?
There are three routes. The City can amend the value after talking to you. You and the City can settle before a hearing, which the dataset records as a mutual agreement. Or the board can lower it after a hearing. All three count as a reduction. A complaint that was withdrawn, confirmed, or raised counts as no reduction.
70% came out lower.
Why the board's own chart shows about 39%
The Assessment Review Board publishes its own statistics page [2]. Its 2025 chart shows decreases granted at about 39% of hearings overall, higher for video and in-person hearings and lower for written ones.
That number and ours measure different things. The board's chart only covers complaints that went all the way to a hearing. Most residential complaints never get there. They settle with the City first, and those settlements almost always mean a lower value: 990 of the 1,008 mutual agreements we checked against the 2025 roll ended in a reduction.
So the hearing rate is the rate for the hard cases, the ones the City was not willing to settle. Ours is the rate for everyone who filed.
What the figure does not tell you
- It is not your odds. People who file are not a random group. Many of them had a specific reason to think their value was wrong.
- It says nothing about size. A $2,000 reduction and a $90,000 reduction both count.
- It is one year. The 2024 roll in the open data was captured before that year's changes were applied, so reductions do not show up in it and we could not use it.
- Our own scoring does not predict who wins. We tested it against these same outcomes and it carried no signal (p = 0.61).
How few people file
CBC Calgary reported that 3,378 complaints were filed in 2025, residential and non-residential together, which is 0.56% of all properties in the city [3]. That is roughly about 1 in 200. The gap between how often filers get a reduction and how rarely anyone files is the reason this site exists.
Check it yourself
You will not land on exactly 1,685 records, because our match to the roll drops complaints whose address does not line up cleanly. You should land close to 70%. If you get something very different, email us. We would rather fix the number than defend it.
- Open the Assessment Review Board complaints dataset on data.calgary.ca and export it as a CSV.
- Filter to residential complaints for the 2025 roll year.
- Look at the decision column. Count mutual agreements, amendments and board decisions with a lower value.
- Compare the value before and after where the dataset carries both.
Questions
- Is the 70% figure from the City?
- The data is the City's. The calculation is ours. We counted 2025 residential complaints in the City's public Assessment Review Board dataset that ended with a lower assessed value.
- Why does the Assessment Review Board report a lower success rate?
- The board's chart covers hearings only, where about 39% of 2025 decisions were decreases. Most residential complaints settle with the City before a hearing, and nearly all of those settlements lower the value.
- Does 70% mean I have a 70% chance?
- No. People who file are not a random sample of homeowners, and the figure counts any reduction regardless of size.
Sources
Check your own address
The lookup compares your assessed value against genuinely comparable homes in your community, and tells you when the public data cannot settle it.
Check your Calgary assessment against comparable homes · What the $49 Evidence Package includes
Last reviewed 2026-10-18. Published by Fair Assessments Calgary, founded by Logan Crook. Sources and method: what the complaint records show.